Forum:Fate of Atlantis

Most of all, I have been an avid player of LucuasArts adventures. I fell in love with Atlantis and only recently, I finally read the comic!! The comic added new insights and details sbut I was a bit disappointed, because the differences between the two are far more numerous and essential than any other differences between film-comic-novelization: Not only names and events have changed, but whole subplots and character roles. The comic-team and the game-team had only few in common to share and were way too free in creating their respective products.

And here comes the matter of canon. If FoA was a movie it would be easy to decide our priority: movies are above c-canon. However here we have to do with two different c-canon sources so there is no clear priority!!

Firstly, I'd like to ask if there is a way to know if the IndyCron has an opinion about this matter? And if not, should Indypedia establish some consistent position in the relevant articles?

The problem is partially covered in the BtS sections but there is still inconsistent format: most articles show preference in one of the two sources, and the BtS comments the difference seen in the other one... however some articles have generic information, leaving the differences analyzed in the BtS. I think we should agree on some editing rules and stick on them until there is some definite answer in the canon question. MoffRebus 14:13, 12 July 2008 (UTC)